Fundraising Product Comparison: Katydids Candy vs. Cookie DoughUsing Katydids Candy vs. Cookie Dough as a Practical Example
🧭 What Makes a Great Fundraising Product Comparison
A great fundraising product comparison goes beyond surface-level features—it highlights how each option aligns with your team’s size, delivery capacity, and audience preferences. It should weigh profit margins, logistics, and emotional appeal, helping you choose not just what sells, but what succeeds in your specific context.
Why Product Choice Matters in Fundraising
A smart fundraising product comparison can make or break your campaign. Choosing the right item isn’t just about popularity—it’s about matching your product to your audience, logistics, and profit goals. Whether you’re selling Katydids candy, cookie dough, or something else entirely, the right fit can boost participation, simplify delivery, and maximize earnings.
For example, a school with limited freezer space might struggle with frozen cookie dough, while a sports team doing door-to-door sales might benefit from compact, shelf-stable items like Katydids.
👉 Explore our full fundraising product catalog
A 5-Point Framework for Comparing Fundraising Products
Use this framework to compare any two products—whether it’s candles vs. popcorn or Katydids vs. cookie dough. The goal is to match your product to your team’s strengths and your supporters’ preferences. This approach helps avoid mismatches that lead to low engagement or logistical headaches.
1. Profit Margin
- Katydids: Higher retail price, but also higher wholesale cost. Ideal for premium campaigns and groups with fewer volunteers. Since the profit per tin is fixed, every sale contributes equally—making it easier to forecast earnings. Unlike cookie dough, which often uses a tiered profit scale based on volume, Katydids can outperform in smaller campaigns. In fact, fundraisers with fewer than 150 sales often raise more with Katydids, thanks to consistent margins and simpler pricing. This predictability is especially helpful for teams with limited outreach capacity or short campaign windows.
- Cookie Dough: Lower price point and lower cost per unit. While the profit margin starts lower, it increases significantly with volume. This makes cookie dough a powerful option for larger teams, school-wide campaigns, or groups with strong outreach. When sales exceed 150–200 units, cookie dough often delivers higher total profits due to bulk incentives and tiered pricing. It’s a scalable model that rewards volume, making it ideal for organizations with broad community reach or digital ordering systems.
2. Packaging and Logistics
- Katydids: Shelf-stable below 76°F, compact tins. Easy to store, transport, and distribute. This makes Katydids ideal for warm climates, rural areas, and campaigns without access to refrigeration. The elegant packaging also adds perceived value, making it a popular choice for holiday drives and gift-oriented fundraisers.
- Cookie Dough: Requires refrigeration or quick delivery. This adds complexity—especially in warm climates or rural areas where cold chain logistics can be costly or unreliable. However, some brands like Neighbors Cookie Dough offer solutions that simplify this process, with better packaging and more flexible delivery options. These innovations make cookie dough more accessible to smaller teams, provided they plan ahead and communicate clearly with buyers.
3. Audience Appeal
- Katydids: Rich and indulgent—great for gifting or seasonal drives. Its premium feel makes it ideal for adult buyers, corporate sponsors, and holiday shoppers. The nostalgic flavor profile also appeals to older demographics who appreciate traditional treats
- Cookie Dough: Universally loved, family-friendly, and available in multiple flavors (including gluten-free). It’s a crowd-pleaser that works well for youth sports, schools, and community groups. The ability to bake fresh cookies at home adds a personal touch that encourages repeat purchases.
4. Distribution Strategy
- Katydids: Ideal for brochure fundraisers, door-to-door sales, and event pickups. Its compact size and stable shelf life allow for flexible distribution—even in hot weather or remote areas. Volunteers can carry tins easily, and supporters can store them without special handling.
- Cookie Dough: May require cold chain or fast delivery to maintain freshness. This means campaigns must coordinate pickup times, refrigeration access, and clear instructions for buyers. While this adds complexity, it also creates urgency—buyers are more likely to act quickly when they know the product is perishable.
5. Long-Term Fit
- Katydids: Great for repeat orders and premium campaigns. Its consistent margins and elegant presentation make it a strong candidate for annual fundraisers, especially those tied to holidays or special events. Groups can build brand recognition around it.
- Cookie Dough: Ideal for seasonal campaigns and broad outreach. Its mass appeal and flavor variety make it perfect for spring or fall drives, especially when paired with digital ordering platforms. Cookie dough also lends itself well to themed promotions, like “Bake for a Cause” or “Cookies for Champions.”
🧭 Final Takeaway: Match Product to Purpose
The best fundraising product isn’t just the one that sells—it’s the one your team can deliver confidently and your supporters will love to share. Use this framework to evaluate your options, and don’t hesitate to mix and match based on your campaign goals.
Ready to Launch Your Fundraiser?
Whether you choose Katydids, cookie dough, or something entirely different, the key is clarity. Use this framework to make confident, data-driven decisions—and watch your campaign thrive.
