🍪 Otis Spunkmeyer vs. Neighbor’s Cookie Dough

🥇 1. Brand Recognition

  • Otis Spunkmeyer:
    ✅ A household name for decades
    ✅ Many supporters recognize it from schools, airports, and vending machines
    ✅ Easy to sell because people already love the brand

  • Neighbor’s Cookie Dough:
    👍 Less widely known, but growing in popularity
    👍 Great taste, but may require more explanation when selling

🏆 Winner: Otis Spunkmeyer


🍪 2. Flavor Selection

  • Otis Spunkmeyer:
    • Offers less innovation but classic options (Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, etc.)
    • Great if you want a simple, easy-to-choose catalog

  • Neighbor’s:
    • Offers a more diverse flavor lineup
    • Includes peanut-free, gluten-free, and seasonal flavors
    • Great for customers with dietary preferences

🏆 Winner: Neighbor’s (for variety)


💵 3. Profit Margins

  • Otis Spunkmeyer:
    • Typically offers 40% profit depending on the distributor
    • May require a minimum order or prepay in some cases

  • Neighbor’s:
    • Also offers up to 50% profit
    • Flexible for small groups, and some programs offer no upfront cost

🏆 Winner: Neighbor’s (more flexible for smaller groups)


🚚 4. Packaging & Delivery

  • Otis Spunkmeyer:
    • Pre-portioned and easy-to-distribute packaging
    • Frozen delivery, good shelf life
    • Easy for parents and schools to manage

  • Neighbor’s:
    • Also frozen, and often comes in both tub and pre-portioned formats
    • Orders arrive grouped by seller, making distribution smooth

🏆 Tie – both are well organized


🎉 5. Selling Experience

  • Otis Spunkmeyer:
    • Easier to sell with name recognition
    • Great for younger students or first-time fundraisers

  • Neighbor’s:
    • Offers more customization and variety
    • Works well for groups that want a modern, flexible approach

🏆 Tie – depends on your group’s needs


🏁 Final Verdict:

CategoryWinner
Brand RecognitionOtis Spunkmeyer
Flavor VarietyNeighbor’s
Profit MarginsNeighbor’s
Packaging & DeliveryTie
Ease of SellingOtis Spunkmeyer

✅ Choose Otis Spunkmeyer if:

  • You want super easy sales with a name everyone trusts
  • You’re working with younger sellers or first-timers
  • You need a simple, no-fuss fundraiser

Choose Neighbor’s Cookie Dough if:

  • You want more variety and customization
  • You need higher profit per sale, or are working with small sized groups
  • Your group is comfortable with a little more marketing effort

🍪 Why Gogo-Fund Chooses Neighbor’s Cookie Dough for Its Customers

1. Unmatched Product Quality

Gogo-Fund only works with cookie dough that’s truly delicious, and Neighbor’s delivers:

  • Gourmet-style dough made with real butter, rich chocolate, and premium ingredients
  • Bakes into soft, chewy cookies that people rave about
  • Zero trans fats, no preservatives—just high-quality, homemade taste

Result: Happy customers = more repeat buyers = more successful fundraisers.


🧁 2. Incredible Flavor Variety

Neighbor’s offers a wider range of flavors than most brands, including:

  • Classics like Chocolate Chip and Snickerdoodle
  • Crowd-pleasers like White Chocolate Macadamia and Triple Chocolate
  • Options for dietary needs, including gluten-free and peanut-free

This variety helps increase average order size—because who wants to pick just one?


💻 3. Superior and easy-to-use brochures

Gogo-Fund prioritizes ease of use, and Neighbor’s supports that with:

  • A vibrant and engaging brochures helps boost sales
  • Volunteers can easily run this fundraiser because of the order taker’s simplicity
  • Fast, simple ordering
  • Possibility to customize the brochure

Bonus: Sellers can add online payment and share their links via social media or text in seconds.


💵 4. Higher Profit Margins

Gogo-Fund offers up to 50% profit per item sold, which is above average in the industry. That means:

  • Schools and groups keep more of the money
  • Even small groups can hit big goals fast
  • No need to oversell just to break even

🚚 5. Smooth Distribution & Packaging

Gogo-Fund values a good experience from start to finish. With Neighbor’s, customers get:

  • Orders sorted by seller for easy distribution
  • Frozen, individually packaged tubs or pre-portioned dough
  • Clear labeling and allergen info

Less confusion = fewer headaches for parents and coordinators.


🤝 6. Aligned with Gogo-Fund’s Mission

Gogo-Fund is all about modern, no-stress fundraising, and Neighbor’s fits that perfectly:

  • No upfront costs
  • Built-in fundraising support
  • Great for schools, teams, churches, and community groups

Together, they make fundraising easier, faster, and way more profitable.


Bottom Line:

Gogo-Fund chooses Neighbor’s Cookie Dough because it offers what customers care about most:

  • Incredible taste
  • Easy selling tools
  • High profits
  • A smooth, reliable experience

Whether you’re a first-time coordinator or a seasoned fundraiser, this partnership gives you a product that practically sells itself.


Need a quick summary, flyer text, we can help with that too!

You can also review the other rewarding choices that are available as an order-taker and brochure.

Leave a Reply